Research

Hypotheses & evidence

Each research question with its evidence status and the outcome observed so far.

Hypotheses HypothesesA hypothesis is a postulate in the research register: a claim about what public data shows, stated so it can be checked, with its evidence status and the outcome observed so far.

1 evidence supported · 7 no reliable evidence · 5 insufficient history

Workbench weightings WeightingsA weighting is a named set of weights and filters that a workbench or a backtest can load. Any weight can be moved; a moved weight makes the weighting custom.

Fund workbench
Stock workbench
Sector workbench
  • Equal Every group counted alike
  • Price Leans on breadth and price strength
  • Flows Leans on fund and foreign flows
  • Business Leans on value and growth

Evidence register Research registerClaims about what public data shows, each stated so it can be checked, with a verdict once a test is finished. A verdict describes a finished sample; none of it is a forecast or advice.

Fund postulates

Claims about what a mutual fund’s own record and disclosures show. Each is measured for every fund and printed on the fund page as a description of the past.

P1Churn, and what it boughtTrading costs something certain; a fund that trades more should show extra return that pays for it.No reliable evidence P1 · Churn, and what it boughtTested; no reliable effect was found. Trading more or less did not separate the funds that did better next.

Trading more or less did not separate the funds that did better next.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · Funds, by turnover · Does any of it predict?

P2Conviction or inertiaLong-held top-ten positions mark a portfolio someone chose; a top ten that changes every quarter is a reaction.No reliable evidence P2 · Conviction or inertiaTested; no reliable effect was found. How long the top holdings are kept did not separate the funds that did better next.

How long the top holdings are kept did not separate the funds that did better next.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · Funds, by how long top holdings are kept · Does any of it predict?

P3Hit rate of the top tenA manager’s largest positions, judged one by one over the next six months, say more than the fund’s blended return.No reliable evidence P3 · Hit rate of the top tenTested; no reliable effect was found. A high hit rate in the top ten did not point to a better next year.

A high hit rate in the top ten did not point to a better next year.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · Funds, by top-ten hit rate · How often is not how much

P4Consistency, not a single end dateA fund that beats its category in most rolling three-year stretches has a record; one that beats it in a few has an end date.No reliable evidence P4 · Consistency, not a single end dateTested; no reliable effect was found. Winning more three-year stretches did not point to a better next year, and winning often was not winning by much.

Winning more three-year stretches did not point to a better next year, and winning often was not winning by much.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · Funds, by average margin · How often is not how much

P5Cost, measuredThe Regular plan (sold through a distributor, who is paid from the fund every day) and the Direct plan hold the same portfolio; the gap between their NAVs is the cost.Evidence supported P5 · Cost, measuredTested; the effect held over the sample tested. The Regular plan cost about 1.2 percentage points a year more than the Direct plan: the one reliable finding in the study.

The Regular plan cost about 1.2 percentage points a year more than the Direct plan: the one reliable finding in the study.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · What the Regular plan costs · Funds, by Regular-plan mark-up

P6Size against edgePast a certain size a fund cannot buy what a small one can, and should charge less in return.No reliable evidence P6 · Size against edgeTested; no reliable effect was found. Smaller funds did slightly better inside their category, but not reliably once many measures were tested together.

Smaller funds did slightly better inside their category, but not reliably once many measures were tested together.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · Funds, by expense ratio · Does any of it predict?

P7Whose record is thisA record earned under different managers is not evidence about the ones running the fund now.No reliable evidence P7 · Whose record is thisTested; no reliable effect was found. The current manager’s own record did not point to a better next year for the fund.

The current manager’s own record did not point to a better next year for the fund.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · Managers · Whose record is it?

P8Manager decisionsScore a fund’s decisions rather than its holdings: adding to a stock that then beat its benchmark, or cutting one that then lagged, is a right call.No reliable evidence P8 · Manager decisionsTested; no reliable effect was found. Manager calls were right about as often as the untouched holdings, so the score reads the portfolio, not the decisions.

Manager calls were right about as often as the untouched holdings, so the score reads the portfolio, not the decisions.

Since 24 Sep 2026 · Does any of it predict?

SIF measures

Specialised Investment Funds (SIFs) are a newer, higher-minimum product regulated alongside mutual funds. They are measured, never rated, and kept out of the paper-money draw.

SIFSIFs, against what they could replaceA Specialised Investment Fund should be judged against the mutual fund it could replace, over its own dates, and by what it costs and when money can be taken out.Insufficient history SIF · SIFs, against what they could replaceMeasured and published; too early for a verdict. Measured and published, never rated; too early for a verdict.

Measured and published, never rated; too early for a verdict.

Since 29 Sep 2026 · SIFs · What the SIF label does not say

Experiment hypotheses

Questions the Fearless trade experiments ask of participants’ paper-money decisions. Answers are published as monthly aggregates only; any group smaller than five people is withheld.

The monthly reveal publishes the aggregate results. Paper money only: prices are a day late, nothing is bought or sold for real, no reward is tied to returns, and it does not train anyone for real trading.

E1Self-picking against a blind drawChoosing a stock or fund oneself does no better than one drawn at random from the same list, over the same dates.Insufficient history E1 · Self-picking against a blind drawMeasured and published; too early for a verdict. Running; participant results publish monthly once groups are large enough.

Running; participant results publish monthly once groups are large enough.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · Monthly reveal · Fearless trade experiments

E2Reading before choosingReading more before choosing — screening, opening a fund’s measures, comparing — changes the result of the choice.Insufficient history E2 · Reading before choosingMeasured and published; too early for a verdict. Running; too few allocations so far for a comparison.

Running; too few allocations so far for a comparison.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · Monthly reveal

E3Exits after a fallSelling after a fall costs money: what was sold goes on to do better than what the money went into.Insufficient history E3 · Exits after a fallMeasured and published; too early for a verdict. Running; too few sales so far for a comparison.

Running; too few sales so far for a comparison.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · Monthly reveal

E4Behaviour: deployment, churn, idle moneyHow money is placed — how much of the monthly amount is put to work, how often positions change, how long paper money sits unused — matters more to the result than which name is chosen.Insufficient history E4 · Behaviour: deployment, churn, idle moneyMeasured and published; too early for a verdict. Running; the aggregate appears once groups are large enough.

Running; the aggregate appears once groups are large enough.

Since 22 Sep 2026 · Monthly reveal

Research context. Not investment advice.