Help / Stocks, sectors and market context

What do the Piotroski, Altman, Beneish and Anveshan scores measure?

Three published accounting scores read from the filed statements, and four Anveshan percentiles placing a company within its industry; none is a forecast.

What it means

Piotroski F scores nine pass-or-fail tests of the latest two years’ accounts, 0 to 9. Altman Z″ combines working capital, reserves, operating profit and book equity into one figure that its author read as safe above 2.6 and distressed below 1.1. Beneish M combines eight ratios that its author found higher where earnings were later restated; above −1.78 is the model’s flag zone. The four Anveshan percentiles (Quality, Growth, Value and Momentum) place a company within its comparison set on Anveshan’s own measures of returns and balance-sheet strength, growth, price against profit, book and dividends, and the price change over six and twelve months.

Where it appears

The score cards on a stock’s Business tab, each with its yearly series; any score can be put in the Summary ratio box.

How it is calculated

The three published scores follow their authors’ formulas on the filed annual figures (the non-manufacturer form of Altman’s score). The Anveshan percentiles combine several measures within the comparison set — the industry, or the sector where the industry has fewer than eight companies with results — and rank the result from 0 to 100; their make-up is Anveshan’s own and is not published.

How it is commonly used

As a summary to read beside the statements: a low Piotroski score or a Beneish flag points at the lines worth reading in the accounts, and a percentile says where a company sits among its peers on one dimension at a time.

Worked example

Illustration: a company whose profit, cash flow and margins rose, whose borrowing and share count did not, and whose turnover and liquidity improved passes all nine tests and scores F = 9. A Quality percentile of 80 means a higher reading than about 80% of its comparison set.

What it does not establish

None of the scores predicts a return, a default or a fraud: a Beneish flag is not a finding of manipulation, an Altman distress reading is not a default, and a high percentile is not a recommendation. A bank or NBFC has no Piotroski, Altman or Beneish score: the tests were built for companies that do not borrow and lend as their business.

Data source and update schedule

The company’s yearly results as filed and the exchange’s daily closes. The percentiles are recomputed weekly; the accounting scores also the morning after a new yearly result.

Related measures

The company ratios, the working-capital days, relative strength.

Evidence status

Descriptive. Whether these scores separate later outcomes among Indian companies has not been established in the evidence register.

Related help

A description of published information, not advice. Nothing on Anveshan is a recommendation to buy, sell, switch or hold an investment. All help · How the evidence is read