What is the behaviour gap, and why is it sometimes unavailable?
The return the funds made against the return the money made given its timing; it needs a statement that lists transactions.
What it means
The behaviour gap is the difference between the yearly return the funds made while money was in them and the yearly return the money itself made, given when it went in and came out. The difference is timing: buying after a rise, selling after a fall, or the reverse.
Where it appears
On a portfolio review’s behaviour findings, and in the comparison of two reviews.
How it is calculated
The funds’ figure is each fund’s NAV growth from the first purchase, weighted by the money put in. The money’s figure is XIRR: the single yearly rate that fits every dated payment in and out. A positive gap means timing cost return.
How it is commonly used
To separate what the funds did from what the timing of money in and out did, over years rather than months.
Worked example
Illustration: the funds compounded at 13% a year while money was in them, but most of the money went in after a strong run and some came out after a fall, so the money’s own XIRR was 10%. The gap is 3 points a year.
What it does not establish
It does not say which decisions caused the gap, whether they were wrong at the time, or what would have been better; a planned withdrawal also shows as timing.
Data source and update schedule
The statement uploaded, and daily NAVs. It needs every transaction: the CAMS or KFintech detailed statement lists every transaction since the first. From an NSDL or CDSL statement, which carries holdings and the month’s transactions only, the timing of money in and out cannot be measured, so the finding is shown as unavailable.
Related measures
XIRR, SIP discipline, chasing, churn, cash drag.
Evidence status
Descriptive of the statement’s own record.
Related help
A description of published information, not advice. Nothing on Anveshan is a recommendation to buy, sell, switch or hold an investment. All help · How the evidence is read