What do the Piotroski F, Altman Z″ and Beneish M readings show?
Three published checklists over the filed accounts: financial strength, financial strain, and signs of earnings management.
What it means
Piotroski F counts nine yes-or-no tests of profit, cash flow, leverage, liquidity, dilution, margin and turnover, 0 to 9. Altman Z″ combines four balance-sheet and earnings ratios in the version for companies that are not manufacturers only. Beneish M combines eight year-on-year ratios that past studies linked with later restatements.
Where it appears
In the Quality and growth group of the filters, and in stock Compare.
How it is calculated
From the latest two filed financial years, with each author’s published definitions. None is read for a bank or lender, whose accounts the checklists were not built for.
How it is commonly used
As a checklist beside the statements: a low Piotroski count or a low Z″ prompts a closer reading of the balance sheet; a high M prompts a closer reading of receivables and accruals.
Worked example
Illustration: a company with rising profit, positive cash flow above profit, falling leverage and no new shares passes four of the nine Piotroski tests on those alone.
What it does not establish
None is a forecast for any one company: they summarise the filed accounts, and past studies found tendencies across many companies, not certainties.
Data source and update schedule
The company’s filed annual statements.
Related measures
ROCE, interest cover, working-capital days, cash flow.
Evidence status
Descriptive here: the published studies are the authors’; Anveshan has not tested these readings on Indian listings.
In Anveshan
Related help
A description of published information, not advice. Nothing on Anveshan is a recommendation to buy, sell, switch or hold an investment. All help · How the evidence is read